Top 10 Best Old-School Italian Restaurants In New York City

When you start looking for the best Italian restaurants in New York City, you quickly realize it is an overwhelming task to find the best of the best. From the classic Italian specialties to the more modern dishes, trying to find the perfect Italian restaurant can take hours. That’s why we have taken the time to compile a list of the top 10 best old-school Italian restaurants in New York City.

Whether you’re looking for classic Italian dishes, or something a bit more modern, these ten restaurants offer a truly unique experience and some of the best traditional Italian food you’ll find in New York City.

  1. John’s of 12th Street

John’s of 12th Street is one of the oldest restaurants in the city and offers some of the best old-school Italian dishes. The restaurant offers a wide variety of Italian classics, like veal parmigiana and eggplant rollatini, as well as more modern Italian dishes like cioppino and lasagna. The highlight of the menu, however, is the fresh homemade pasta dishes.

  1. Patsy’s

Located in the heart of midtown, Patsy’s is an Italian institution. It has been serving classic Italian dishes since 1944. The menu includes all of the classic Italian favorites like eggplant parmigiana, linguine with clam sauce, and chicken marsala. The atmosphere is warm and cozy, and it’s a great spot for date night.

  1. Emilia’s

Emilia’s is a small, family-owned restaurant in the heart of the West Village. It has been serving classic Italian dishes since 1986; its menu features fresh handmade pastas and classic dishes like lasagna and veal parmigiana. The unique thing about Emilia’s is the atmosphere; it feels like you stepped into a home kitchen in old-school Italy.

  1. SalE Pepe

Located in the East Village, SalE Pepe is a classic Italian restaurant with a modern twist. The restaurant serves traditional Italian dishes like veal saltimbocca and pasta puttanesca, but also features fresh handmade organic pastas and sustainable wines. The highlight of the menu, however, is the extensive selection of Roman-style pizzas.

  1. Manganaro’s Gristida

Manganaro’s Gristida is an old-school Italian restaurant located in Little Italy. It has been serving classic Italian favorites since 1905 and is well known for its homemade pastas and famous arancini. The menu also features classic Italian dishes like veal and ricotta meatballs as well as more modern dishes like pork and beef braciole.

  1. Mario’s

Mario’s is a no-frills Italian restaurant located on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx. It has been serving the Bronx since 1919 and is known for its homemade pastas and classic Italian dishes like cheesy lasagna and eggplant parmigiana. The restaurant is cozy and intimate and the atmosphere is reminiscent of a traditional Italian kitchen.

  1. Marea

Marea is an upscale Italian dining experience in Midtown Manhattan. It features modern Italian cuisine with a focus on fresh seafood and homemade pastas. The menu features a variety of dishes like squid ink spaghetti and raw cuttlefish and octopus. The atmosphere is warm and upscale and it’s a perfect spot for a special occasion.

  1. Casa di Mama

Casa di Mama is a small Italian restaurant located in Chelsea. It has been serving Italian-American favorites like veal piccata and chicken parmigiana for over 20 years. The atmosphere is cozy and familial, and the restaurant offers an extensive selection of Italian wines to accompany your meal.

  1. Del Posto

Del Posto is an upscale Italian restaurant located on the edge of the Meatpacking District. It serves Italian classics with a modern twist like truffled egg yolk ravioli and pan-seared foie gras. The atmosphere is elegant and the menu features an extensive selection of Italian wines.

  1. San Marzano

San Marzano is a small Italian restaurant located in the East Village. It serves traditional Italian dishes with a focus on fresh ingredients and local produce. The menu features favorites like eggplant parmesan and bucatini with meatballs and a variety of hand-tossed pizzas. The atmosphere is cozy and intimate and it’s a great spot for date night.

New York City has no shortage of great Italian restaurants. Whether you’re looking for traditional Italian dishes or something more modern, these ten restaurants offer some of the best old-school Italian food in the city. From classic Italian dishes to modern takes on traditional cuisine, there’s something for everyone at these old-school Italian restaurants. So if you’re looking for a truly unique dining experience, look no further than these ten old-school Italian restaurants in New York City.